She started laughing. Then crying. Then laughing again. She put her face in her hands at her own kitchen table and shook.
“Three years,” she said. “Three years I’ve been eating toast. Three years I’ve been taking food home from my children’s tables because I thought I’d go hungry.”
“I know.”
“And it was here,” she said. “All of it. In a basket. On my table.”
She looked up at me.
“Cliff always said I’d never have to worry about money,” she said. “He said, Bernie, I’ve got it all set up. You’ll never be hungry again. I promise.” Her voice broke. “And I didn’t believe him. I didn’t believe him for one second. Because I’d been hungry for fifty years and I didn’t know how to stop.”
Chapter Nine: Neil
Neil came over that evening.
I called him from Bernadine’s kitchen and told him to come. I didn’t tell him why. I just said, “Your mother needs you.”
He was there in twenty minutes. He came in the front door in his Kimball jacket. He found us in the laundry room.
He stopped in the doorway.
He looked at the containers. Stacked on the dryer. On the washer. On the floor. A hundred little masking-tape labels.
He looked at the freezer, open, almost empty.
He looked at his mother.
“Mom,” he said. “What is all this?”
She told him. All of it. Standing in the laundry room in her church dress with her coat off. Her childhood. The wings and the backs. Cliff fixing the kids’ plates. The day he died. The containers.
Neil didn’t say anything. He just listened.
When she got to Cliff’s plate, she walked over to the freezer and reached down to the very bottom and brought it up.
She held it out to him.
Neil looked at it for a long time.
THANKSGIVING 2022. CLIFF’S PLATE.
He took it from her. He held it in both hands. His father’s hands.
“You saved it,” he said.
“I couldn’t throw it away,” she whispered.
He looked down at it. Through the cloudy plastic. At the corner of dressing. Brown on two edges.
“He always took the corner,” Neil said. “When I was little. Every holiday. He’d fix our plates and then he’d fix his and he’d always take the corner. And I’d get mad.” He almost smiled. “And then when I was about Jonah’s age, he started giving me the corner. Every year. He’d fix my plate first and put the corner on it and he wouldn’t say anything.”
He looked at his mother.
“I never knew,” he said, “that he was giving it up for me.”
Bernadine reached out. She put her hand on his arm.
“He’d give up anything for you kids,” she said. “Anything. He used to say, Bernie, I’ll eat last forever, if it means they never have to.”
Neil put the container down on the dryer. Very carefully. He turned around. He put his arms around his mother.
She held on to him. Five foot two and six foot three. In the laundry room. Surrounded by three years of frozen dinners.
“I’m sorry, Mom,” Neil said into her hair. “For what I said. At Thanksgiving. In front of everybody.”
“You were right,” she said into his chest.
“I know,” Neil said. “But I’m still sorry.”
We cleaned out the freezer that night. All three of us.
Most of it had to go. Three years is too long, even frozen. Freezer burn on the turkey. Ice crystals in the potatoes. Renee would know, she’s a nurse. Neil called her. She came over at seven with garbage bags and her reading glasses.
She took one look at the laundry room and sat down on the floor and cried.
Then she got up and helped.
We sorted them. The ones from this year that still looked good, we stacked on the counter. Bernadine would eat them this week. She promised.
The rest went in garbage bags. One container at a time. Bernadine read each label out loud before it went in the bag.
“Easter 2023. Renee’s. Ham.”
“Fourth of July 2023. Neil’s. Corn.”
“Jonah’s birthday. 2024. Cake.”
Like she was saying goodbye to each one.
When we got to the bottom, there was only one left.
Cliff’s plate.
Bernadine picked it up. She held it for a long time.
“I don’t know what to do with this one,” she said.
Nobody said anything.
Then Neil said, “Mom. Do you want to take it to him?”
So on Monday morning, we did.
St. Joseph Cemetery. On the hill above Jasper, behind the church. Cliff’s grave is in the newer section, by an oak tree. A gray granite headstone with a carpenter’s square carved on it, for his union.
CLIFFORD J. SCHNELL. 1955 to 2022. BELOVED HUSBAND AND FATHER.
Bernadine stood in front of it in her good coat, holding the container.
Neil and Renee and I stood behind her. And Jonah. Jonah came too. He insisted.
She didn’t open it. She didn’t bury it. She just knelt down on the cold grass in front of his headstone and set it there. At the base. Next to the little pot of mums Renee brought for Halloween.
“I fixed your plate, Cliff,” she said. Very quietly. “Like I always do. You’ve just got to eat it now. I can’t hold onto it anymore.”
She stayed there on her knees for a long time.
Then she stood up. She picked the container back up. She held it against her chest.
She walked to the trash can by the cemetery gate, and she set it inside. Gently. The way you’d lay something down in a casket.
Then she turned around and walked back to us.
Chapter Ten: Christmas
She came to Christmas.
At our house. Outside Ferdinand. Fourteen people again. Same chairs. Same table with the leaf in. Same card table, which Neil dug out of the garage two days early this time.
She came at noon. She brought her canvas tote bag.
My stomach dropped when I saw it.
She set it on the kitchen counter. She didn’t open it.
She took off her coat and hung it on the hook. She came into the kitchen. I was basting the ham. She stood beside me at the stove.
“What can I do?” she asked.
I looked at her. In her red Christmas sweater with the reindeer on it. She’d gotten her hair done. She’d gained a little weight. Her cheeks had color.
“You could mash the potatoes,” I said. “Jonah peeled them.”
“Forty-six of them,” Jonah announced from the kitchen table. “I counted.”

