My father took a plea deal in July.
His lawyer, a well-known Denver criminal defense attorney named Victor Galloway who charged $650 an hour, negotiated it. My father pleaded guilty to two felony counts: forgery and identity theft. The other charges were dismissed.
He was sentenced to five years of supervised probation and four hundred hours of community service, and ordered to pay restitution. He was to pay me $47,000 for the fraudulent credit card debt and damage to my credit, plus $16,800 for my attorneyās fees in the quiet title action. Separately, he owed the title insurance company the full $410,000 it paid to clear the home equity loan, plus interest.
To pay it, he had to sell his commercial real estate business. He and my mother moved into a two-bedroom rental apartment in Aurora.
I was in the courtroom when the judge sentenced him. She was an older woman with reading glasses on a beaded chain, and before she handed down the sentence, she asked my father if he had anything to say.
He stood up slowly. Heād lost weight, and his suit hung loose on his shoulders.
He turned around, not toward the judge, but toward me in the second row.
āNora,ā he said. His voice was rough. āMy mother tried to tell me who I was becoming. For years, she tried. I wouldnāt listen. I thought I deserved that house because I grew up in it, because I was her son. I thought you didnāt need it, because you had the Army.ā He swallowed. āI thought youād never come home.ā
The courtroom was silent.
āWhen Mom died, and you didnāt come to the funeral, I told myself you didnāt care. That youād chosen your career over your family. I told everybody that. I told Tiffany. I told your mother.ā His eyes filled. āAnd the whole time, you were somewhere Iāll never know about, doing something Iāll never understand, and my mother was the only one who knew the truth. She knew, and she protected you from me.ā
He wiped his eyes.
āIām sorry, Nora,ā he said. āIām sorry I made you a stranger in your own family. Iām sorry I took Momās picture off the wall. I didnāt want her watching me do it.ā
I didnāt say anything. I didnāt owe him anything, not yet.
But I nodded once, and he saw it.
That night, my mother called me for the first time in five years.
āI knew,ā she said. She was crying. āNot about the forgery. Not at first. But I knew something was wrong, and I didnāt ask. Your father always handled the money, and I never asked. I just went along. It was easier.ā She took a long, shaky breath. āYour grandmother told me once that the worst thing a mother can do is be easy. I didnāt understand what she meant until now.ā
āMom,ā I said.
āI took her picture off the wall myself,ā she said. āYour father asked me to. I put it in a box in the garage. Iām so sorry, Nora. Iām so sorry.ā
āWhereās the box now?ā
āI still have it,ā she said. āIn the storage unit. I couldnāt throw it away.ā
āBring it to the house,ā I said. āSaturday morning. Iāll make coffee.ā
There was a long silence on the line.
āYou want me to come to the house?ā she whispered.
āIt was your home for twenty-six years too, Mom,ā I said. āBring the picture.ā
She came that Saturday at ten oāclock.
She pulled into the driveway in a used Honda Civic. The Lexus had been sold to help pay the restitution. She sat in the car for five minutes before she got out, holding a cardboard box against her chest.
I opened the front door before she could knock.
She stood on the porch where Grandma Maggie stood at twenty-five in a dark wool coat and pearls, and she held out the box with both hands like an offering.
āIām sorry,ā she said again.
āI know, Mom,ā I said. āCome inside.ā
We hung the photograph back on the wall behind the desk in what used to be Grandmaās sewing room. Iād moved my fatherās things out in the spring and moved Grandmaās sewing machine back in from the basement. The lighter rectangle on the wallpaper was still there. When we hung the frame, it covered it exactly.
Grandma Maggie looked down at us from the wall, young and proud on the front steps of the house she would live in for fifty-three years.
My mother stood looking at it with tears running down her face.
āShe was so beautiful,ā she said.
āShe still is,ā I said.
General Hart came to dinner the following Sunday. He brought a pot roast heād made himself, from Grandmaās recipe, and told stories about her Iād never heard. Sheād once chased a drunk sergeant out of the Fort Carson post hospital with a mop. She taught three generations of young lieutenants to write thank-you notes. He said she was the toughest woman heād ever met, and that heād met a few.
Tiffany came too. Sheād moved into a small studio apartment in Capitol Hill and found a job managing social media for a nonprofit that helps military families. She stood in the doorway of the sunroom for a long time, looking at Grandmaās African violets.
āCan I still water them?ā she asked quietly. āOn Sundays?ā
āTheyāre your violets, Tiff,ā I said. āGrandma gave them to you. Come water them any time you want.ā
She cried, just a little, and then she watered them.
My father didnāt come. He wasnāt ready, and neither was I. But in October, a letter arrived at the house in his handwriting. Inside was a single photograph Iād never seen: me at about seven years old on Grandmaās lap in the sunroom, both of us laughing at something outside the frame.
On the back heād written: āShe always said youād come home. I should have believed her.ā
I put it on the mantel.
